"I have used Stacey's products for a number of years, BUT this duo Mascara is a disaster! Very thick and cloggy and, even after removing it in the evening, I waken up with huge panda eyes! Also, an hour or so of applying it during the day, it has smuged beneath my eyes - not a good look! Unfortunately it is a duo, so I shall just have to bin both, as I had not begun to use it before the 30 day return service. Disappointed, Stacey!!"